Mr. Paul J. Cagle, MD, Sports Medicine Specialist
We verify the medical license of each FindaTopDoc Verified Doctor to ensure that their license is active and they are in good medical standing.

Mr. Paul J. Cagle, MD

Orthopaedic Surgeon

425 West 59th Street 5th Floor New York NY, 10019



Dr. Paul Cagle Jr. is a board certified orthopaedic surgeon, Assistant Professor and Associate Program Director at Mt. Sinai specializing in shoulder and elbow surgery. Dr Cagle currently focuses on shoulder and elbow surgery spanning from sports injuries, to rotator cuff tears, to minimally invasive surgery, to fracture care to joint replacement for arthritis. He started his career at SIU where he was the Orthopaedic Surgery Department Chair and head of Clinical and Translational Research. During his education, he completed a shoulder and elbow fellowship at Mount Sinai, and he chose to follow his fellowship with additional training in shoulder replacement, shoulder stabilization and rotator cuff repair in Lyon, France with acclaimed shoulder surgeon Dr. Gilles Walch. He graduated with honors from St. Ambrose University where he was a collegiate football athlete and a two time Academic All-America Scholar Athlete. He earned his medical degree at Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine, and he then completed his orthopeadic surgery residency at the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis.

Education and Training

Icahn School of Medicine Mount Sinai Shoulder and Elbow Fellowship 2014

University of Minnesota Orthopaedic Surgery Residency 2013

Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine MD 2008

Board Certification

American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery

Provider Details

Male English

Areas of expertise and specialization

Shoulder SurgerySports MedicineJoint ReplacementRotator Cuff RepairLabral TearsShoulder InstabilitySports InjuriesShoulder FracturesElbow FracturesElbow InjuriesThrowing Injuries

Faculty Titles & Positions

  • Assistant Professor Icahn School of Medicine Mount Sinai 2016 - 2017
  • Associate Program Director Mount Sinai Department of Orthopaedic Surgery 2016 - 2017


  • Gold Humanism Award 2012  

Professional Memberships

  • American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons  

Areas of research

Shoulder Surgery, Sports Medicine, Minimally Invasive Surgery, Fracture Surgery

Mr. Paul J. Cagle, MD's Practice location

Mt Sinai West

425 West 59th Street 5th Floor -
New York, NY 10019
Get Direction
New patients: 212-523-7584, 212-523-7584
Fax: 212-636-3102

Mount Sinai Doctors Orthopedic Surgery

5 East 98th Street 9th Floor -
New York, NY 10029
Get Direction
New patients: 212-636-8888

Mr. Paul J. Cagle, MD's reviews

Write Review

Patient Experience with Dr. Cagle


Based on 1 reviews

Mr. Paul J. Cagle, MD has a rating of 5 out of 5 stars based on the reviews from 1 patient. FindaTopDoc has aggregated the experiences from real patients to help give you more insights and information on how to choose the best Orthopaedic Surgeon in your area. These reviews do not reflect a providers level of clinical care, but are a compilation of quality indicators such as bedside manner, wait time, staff friendliness, ease of appointment, and knowledge of conditions and treatments.
  • (5)

Media Releases

Get to know Orthopaedic Surgeon Dr. Paul J. Cagle, who serves patients throughout the State of New York. 

Dr. Cagle is an internationally recognized board-certified orthopaedic surgeon who specializes in shoulder surgery, elbow surgery, and sports medicine. He provides the most cutting-edge treatment of shoulder issues such as rotator cuff tears, shoulder arthritis, shoulder joint replacement, shoulder instability, labral tears, shoulder or elbow fractures, dislocations, biceps tendon rupture, pectoralis ruptures, shoulder separation, bursitis, impingement, tennis elbow, cubital tunnel syndrome, throwing injuries, and weight lifting/fitness injuries. At present, he serves as an Assistant Professor of Orthopaedics and the Associate Program Director of the Orthopaedics Surgery Program at the prestigious Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai. 

He is also affiliated with the Mount Sinai Health network. More specifically, he tends to patients at Mount Sinai West Hospital-Patient Office, Mount Sinai Brooklyn Heights, and Mount Sinai Union Square. He performs surgical procedures at the Mount Sinai West and Mount Sinai Downtown Hospital locations.

“I feel truly privileged to use the knowledge and experience I have gained through working with true leaders in the field of surgery to provide thoughtful, timely, and advanced care to my patients. My commitment is to always be mindful of my patient’s family, occupational and personal needs while improving their lives and conditions as quickly and as safely as possible. I believe in a team-centered approach, offering and utilizing nonsurgical treatments first and surgical interventions only when absolutely necessary. Each person is an individual, and they deserve a treatment plan designed for them.” as stated by the doctor. 

During his collegiate years, Dr. Cagle was a two-time Academic All-America Scholar-Athlete in the sport of football, and he reflects on these years to help understand and treat athletes at all levels today. He attended medical school in his hometown of Chicago at Loyola University Stritch School of Medicine, where he was a recipient of the Arnold P. Gold Humanism and Excellence in Teaching Award. He then went on to complete his residency in orthopaedic surgery at the University of Minnesota in Minneapolis in 2013, followed by his shoulder & elbow fellowship at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai in 2014. From there, he traveled to Lyon, France for additional subspecialty training at one of the most recognized shoulder and elbow fellowships in the world.  

A Fellow of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, the doctor is board-certified in orthopaedic surgery by the American Board of Orthopaedic Surgery, an organization with the goal of establishing educational and professional standards for orthopaedic residents and surgeons, as well as evaluating the qualifications and competence of orthopaedic surgeons. 

An emerging leader in the American Orthopaedic Association and an elected member of the American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons, Dr. Cagle has published over 30 peer-reviewed scientific articles and book chapters, as well as has presented nationally and internationally at scientific conferences. He holds patent rights for medical device development and continues to be at the forefront of medical education.

Orthopaedic surgery is the branch of surgery concerned with conditions involving the musculoskeletal system. Orthopaedic surgeons use both surgical and nonsurgical means to treat musculoskeletal trauma, spine diseases, sports injuries, degenerative diseases, infections, tumors, and congenital disorders. They work in clinical and hospital settings.

Recognized as a Super Doctor, New York Top Doctor, and New York State Trooper/Police Surgeon, Dr. Cagle has been quoted in the New York Post, the New York Daily News, and Newsday.

Recommended Articles

  • When to Be Concerned About Sternum Pain

    IntroductionThe sternum, also called as the breastbone, is a flat bone situated at the center of the chest. It connects to the ribs through cartilages and forms the front of the rib cage, which helps protect the lungs, heart, and major blood vessels from injuries. Since the sternum is near to the...

  • What Is the Xiphoid Process?

    Introduction The xiphoid process is the smallest part or structure of the breastbone. The structure is made of cartilage at birth, but tends to develop into a bony structure when an individual reaches adulthood. It is situated from where the lower ribs are attached to the breastbone. The pointed end...

  • Different Types of Physicians Explained

    Doctors or physicians are categorized according to different factors including medical specialties and subspecialties. Most doctors specialize in a specific area of medicine. This article provides a summary of the different types of doctors in the medical field. AllergistsAllergists are also...

  • What Conditions Does a Bone Doctor Treat?

    What is a bone doctor?A bone doctor is also known as an orthopedist or an orthopedic surgeon. Bone doctors specialize in the diagnosis and treatment of musculoskeletal injuries, diseases, and conditions. Their practice is also seen in other areas, such as pediatrics, sports medicine, trauma,...

  • Pain Between the Shoulder Blades

    IntroductionPain between the shoulder blades is also known as interscapular pain. It is a symptom that is often caused by minor issues, such as a muscle strain. However, being aware of such symptom is also very important since it may also be a sign of more serious conditions, such as lung cancer...

  • Broken Tibia: Symptoms and Treatment

    OverviewThe tibia and fibula are the two bones in your lower leg. The larger bone is the tibia, which supports most of a person's weight. It is also an important part of the ankle and knee joints. A fractured or broken tibia is usually along the length of the bone and in between the knee and above...

Nearby Providers

Nearest Hospitals



Head northwest on West 59th Street 137 ft
You have arrived at your destination, on the left



Head northwest on West 59th Street 435 ft
Turn right onto Amsterdam Avenue 1561 ft
Turn right onto West 65th Street 1796 ft
Continue straight onto 65th Street Transverse 2906 ft
Continue straight onto East 65th Street 1054 ft
Turn left onto Park Avenue 3450 ft
Turn right onto East 78th Street 469 ft
Turn right onto Lexington Avenue 265 ft
Turn right onto East 77th Street 264 ft
You have arrived at your destination, on the left



Head northwest on West 59th Street 435 ft
Turn right onto Amsterdam Avenue 258 ft
Turn right onto West 60th Street 897 ft
Turn right onto Columbus Avenue 1.3 mi
Turn left onto West 34th Street 250 ft
You have arrived at your destination



Head southeast on East 98th Street 265 ft
Turn left onto Madison Avenue 787 ft
Turn left onto East 101st Street 505 ft
Turn left onto 5th Avenue 256 ft
Turn left onto Gustave L. Levy Place 133 ft
You have arrived at your destination, on the right



Head southeast on East 98th Street 737 ft
Turn right onto Park Avenue 542 ft
Turn left onto East 96th Street 551 ft
Turn right onto Lexington Avenue 5097 ft
Turn right onto East 77th Street 264 ft
You have arrived at your destination, on the left



Head southeast on East 98th Street 737 ft
Turn right onto Park Avenue 542 ft
Turn left onto East 96th Street 1055 ft
Turn left onto 3rd Avenue 282 ft
Turn right onto East 97th Street 859 ft
Turn left 86 ft
Turn left 251 ft
You have arrived at your destination, on the left